Samsung Galaxy S20's "5G" looks like t-Mobile's bullsh*t

Samsung Galaxy S20's "5G" looks like t-Mobile's bullsh*t

Well, this week I was shooting a video review of the $1,400 Samsung Galaxy S20 Ultra. No such luck, however.

On T-Mobile's 5G network, I fired up the Speedtest.net app to see what download speeds the S20 Ultra could get in midtown Manhattan. I got 32.5 Mbps near Bryant Park, but only 7.46 Mbps in Times Square. Is this 5G?

To be fair, the S20 Ultra did achieve much faster downloads in Brooklyn, with 98.9 Mbps down in one test, but curiously, the Speediest app's results menu showed the phone as being on LTE.

Overall, the S20 averaged 25 Mbps download over several weeks, which is quite weak.

Now, this is just one app, so I decided to download some web pages alongside the iPhone 11 Pro Max, an LTE device on Verizon's network. In some cases, the T-Mobile network was faster on the Galaxy S20 Ultra, but in other cases, the 4G iPhone loaded sites and articles faster.

As a real-world test in an alternate universe, I downloaded a 51-minute Altered Carbon season 2 episode on Netflix using T-Mobile's "5G." Seeing that the progress meter barely moved after a minute, I gave up.

So what's going on, as PCMag's Sascha Segan explained, is that T-Mobile 5G and AT&T 5G are now using low-band LTE in most places, offering speeds close to 4G. The situation should improve as the carriers build out their networks, but for now the 5G icon appears to be a big lie.

Meanwhile, Verizon's 5G network boasts speeds in excess of 1 Gbps on the carrier's mmWave-based network. Verizon's 5G is difficult to reach indoors, as it requires being near a Verizon node. Still, it is commendable that Verizon only displays the 5G icon when 5G performance is available.

We ran several speed tests in Bryant Park using Verizon's Galaxy S20 Ultra and recorded download speeds of 1.4 Gbps. This is much faster than T-Mobile's network.

We also downloaded a 46-minute episode of "Altered Carbon 2" on Verizon's 5 network in just 5 seconds. Yes, five seconds.

Sprint's 5G network is in the middle of the pack, typically at speeds of 200-300 Mbps in the 2.5 GHz midband spectrum. Not bad, given that it does not require a line-of-sight to achieve these speeds.

More speed tests will be conducted with the Galaxy S20 Ultra, Galaxy S20, and Galaxy S20 Plus using all of these networks. But I want to warn you now that, at least based on my experience, T-Mobile's 5G does not feel like 5G at all right now.

Categories