I tried Netflix's Play Something feature, but the results surprised me

I tried Netflix's Play Something feature, but the results surprised me

This may look familiar: You're sitting on the couch, scrolling aimlessly through Netflix. I examine my list, peruse the various columns vertically and horizontally, and tab through the "Movies and TV Shows" section. Hours (or even decades) later, I still can't pick a title. And every week I write a "what to watch this weekend" guide. It's easy for me.

To cure the blues of indecisive people like me, Netflix rolled out "Play Something" earlier this year. This is a shuffle feature of sorts, literally playing something that does exactly what its name implies. It is not completely random, but based on preferences and tastes indicated by past viewing history. But you don't have to choose, the algorithm does it for you.

I was quite skeptical when this service was launched. Furthermore, it wasn't (and still isn't) available on the Netflix Apple TV app, so I had forgotten it existed. However, while testing the Roku Streaming Stick 4K Plus, I noticed the Play Something option and decided to give it a try. The results were not at all what I had imagined.

My initial expectation for Play Something was that it would function as a sort of discovery mode. A sort of Netflix version of my article on shows and movies to watch after The Squid Game. Kind of like a Netflix version of my article on shows and movies to watch after The Squid Game.

In fact, Netflix has so many films that the size of its library is immeasurable. The size of its library is immeasurable. My friends sometimes talk excitedly about Netflix shows I've never even heard of. Still, the breadth and depth of the programming makes it extremely difficult to discover on my own, and the thematic rows on the Netflix home screen are not particularly helpful. 'Near-future sci-fi,' indeed. I can understand "because you're watching [insert title]." But "exciting TV shows" seems too broad. And "mood booster." Whatever.

These columns further exacerbate my indecision. I start debating in private whether "Startup" is really a "familiar TV show" or not, and I am puzzled as to why "Criminal Minds" is in the "award-winning TV show" category.

When I find something that looks interesting, I don't play it right away. I add it to my list, make a note of it, and keep scrolling, hoping that I might find something better among the zillions of other shows. This is a classic case of selection paralysis, and that's where Play Something comes in.

One evening I launched Netflix and selected the Play Something option. It took me 15 skips to discover a title that was new to me. Either I had already watched something, was in the middle of watching something, or wasn't interested.

Below are the 15 Play Something pieces I got:

None of these suggestions deviated much from my taste. As you can see, most of them are shows I have either seen or am in the process of watching. To be fair, Netflix explains that Play Something offers entirely new series and movies, series and movies that I have already seen, series and movies that are on my list, and unfinished series and movies that I might want to revisit.

And you can't blame Netflix for not noticing if you've watched a show elsewhere, such as on a broadcast station, cable TV, or other streaming service (although an "already watched" button would be neat). For example, I watched the first five seasons of "Shits Creek" on Netflix, but tuned into "Pop TV" to watch the last episode. I am one of the millions who watched "My Neighbor Seinfeld" when it aired on NBC. I have plans to rewatch it on Netflix at some point, so it's an understandable suggestion.

But in general, my Play Something results indicate that it is more of a reminder to catch up on shows I am behind on than a discovery tool. Yes, yes, I know there are new episodes of Sex Education and Money Heist. I promise. However, Netflix already has a feature that reminds you to watch a show you started watching again. It's called "Keep Watching" (and I hate it).

Only the 15th one, "On the Verge," was new to me (I had heard about the Julie Delpy series, but it had slipped my mind); 1 out of 15 is not a great It's not a great track record. It takes time to process the title that is playing, press next, and then see the new program in the queue. At that point, it takes almost as long as scrolling.

Speaking of saving time, for those with less-than-ideal internet connections, Netflix is getting an upgrade that will make it easier to stream videos on a slow connection.

I didn't expect Play Something to be perfect and find exactly one or two recommendations that fit my mood at a particular moment. But I did expect that it would at least alleviate some of my decision paralysis. Instead, it added a different kind of anxiety to my Netflix experience. Perhaps if I were the type of person who wakes up and chooses chaos, "Play Something" would be perfect.

For now, I will continue to scroll, scroll, scroll.

.

Categories